Welcome to Don’t Argue Slice Shop

Artisan Style New York Pizza. Don’t Argue! Eat pizza... 

CATERING

Yes, we cater! From an office party to an at-home celebration, we can help with your next event. Please email or call to inquire (yes!) 

OUR PIZZA MENU

STARTERS

House Salad
10

Greens, Fresh Veg, Chick Pea, Oil & Vinegar

Radicchio Caesar Salad
12

Radicchio, Romaine, House Croutons, House Dressing, Grana Padano

Caprese Salad
12

Tomato, Fior Di Latte, Basil, Olive Oil

Antipasto Plate
9

Meat, Cheese, Veg

Garlic Knots
9

Pizza Dough tossed with Garlic, Parsley, Parm, Side Of Tomato Sauce

Mixed Olives
7

SALTIMBOCCA SUBS

Roasted sub on house made, wood fired bread. Finished with tomato, arugula and basil mayo.

The Cheech
13

Mortadella, Ham, Salami, Fresh Mozzarella

Prosciutto & Arugula
13

Prosciutto Grudo, Fresh Mozzarella

Piccante
13

Capicollo, Sopressata, Fresh Mozzarella

Sergio Tacchino
13

Roast Turkey, Fresh Mozzarella

Joe Grinder
13

Italian Sausage, Peppers, Onion, Fresh Mozzarella

Caprese
13

Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil

Vinny Verdi
13

Eggplant, Artichoke, Red Pepper, Fresh Mozzarella

BUILD YOUR OWN PIE

25 (PLUS TOPPINGS)

Toppings 3.5 each

Extra Cheese
Ricotta
Vegan Mozz
Pepperoni
Sausage
Ham
Salami
Hot Salami
Capicollo
Basil
Garlic
Mushroom
Olive
Artichoke
Red Onion
Whipped Potato
Green Pepper
Braised Kale
Eggplant
Pineapple
Pesto

PIES (XL)

The Standard
25

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Grana Padano

Margherita
28

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Fior di Latte, Grana Padano, Basil

Potato Mash
32

White Sauce, Mozz, Garlic, Whipped Potato, Braised Kale, Red Onion

Pesto Ricotta
30

White Sauce, Mozz, Ricotta, Pesto, Basil

Sausage Kale
30

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Italian Sausage, Braised Kale

Pancetta Pineapple
32

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Ham, Pancetta, Pineapple, Oregano

Pepperoni
30

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Jersey Pepperoni

Pepperoni Mushroom
32

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Jersey Pepperoni, Mushroom

Vodka Pie
28

Vodka Sauce, Mozz, Basil

Vodka Pepperoni
34

Vodka Sauce, Mozz, Jersey Pepperoni, Basil, Honey

Hot Capicollo
32

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Hot Salami, Capicollo

Capricciosa
34

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Ham, Mushroom, Olive, Artichoke

Deluxe Pie
36

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Ham, Sausage, Green Pepper, Mushroom, Olive

Three Cheese
32

Cream Sauce, Garlic, Parsley, Mozz, Ricotta, Grana Padano

Veggie Pie
32

Tomato Sauce, Mozz, Mushroom, Eggplant, Green Pepper, Red Onion, Olive

Substitutions
1.5
Sub Vegan Mozz
1.5

Sorry, no half and half

DESSERT

Tiramisu
7

Ladyfingers, Mascarpone, Coffee, Rum

Affogato
7

Soft Serve, Shot of Espresso

Soft Serve Ice Cream
5

Feature Flavours or Twist

OUR DRINKS MENU

COCKTAILS

Negroni (3oz)
13

Campari, Gin, Antica Formula Carpano

Spritz (2oz)
11

Aperol Or Limoncello Or Campari, Prosecco, Soda

Sbagliato (2oz)
12

"Mistaken Negroni": Campari, Prosecco, Antica Formula Carpano

Amaro & Tonic (1.5oz)
9.5

Amaro, Tonic, On The Rocks

HOUSE WINE (5oz)

Cantina Tollo, Abruzzo, Italy

White Trebbiano
9
Red Sangiovese
9

BOTTLED BEER (330ml)

Peroni
8
Moretti
8

DIGESTIVI (1oz/2oz)

Amari
8/13

Montenegro, The Woods, Odd Society, Fernet Branca, Cynar

Grappe
8/13

"Piedrosso" Russo, Nonino, Nonino Di Barique

Liquori
8/13

Limoncello, Sambuca, Vermouth, Brandy, Amaretto, Frangelico